Tribes and fishermen slam Trump plan to export more water from the Delta By Dan Bacher
Members of the Yurok Tribe on the Klamath River, Hoopa Valley Tribe on the Trinity River, Winnemem Wintu Tribe on the McCloud River and the Pit River Tribe joined with commercial and recreational fishing groups and Restore the Delta to protest Trump administration water grab in front of the federal building on Capitol Mall in Sacramento on January 23.
Many of them also later testified at a public comment period inside the building to to voice their opposition against the Trump Administration’s proposal to “maximize water deliveries” to the federal Central Valley Project. In fact, every single one of the 15 people that spoke at the meeting testified against the increased exports plan.
They spoke to stop a propose to increase Delta exports to agribusiness interests that could devastate populations of salmon, steelhead and other fish species on the Sacramento, Feather, American, San Joaquin, Trinity, and Klamath Rivers at a time when salmon populations on many rivers and Delta smelt numbers have reached historic lows.
A large number of project opponents arrived in the federal building late because they had wait in a long line as they proceeded through Homeland Security. I personally spent 30 minutes in line as the security checked I.D.s. and ran our belongings through the security cameras.
It is telling that not one single person spoke in favor of the project in the Sacramento meeting.
“The Bureau of Reclamation needs to deeply consider the greater detrimental environmental effects that are already evident from manipulating natural water systems,” said Klamath Justice Coalition member and Yurok Tribal Member Annelia Hillman, before the rally. “On the Klamath River, we can testify to the damage that reservoirs and diversions have caused on tribal subsistence fishing, water quality and all life dependent on it.”
“We are all aware that maximizing water flows to the Central Valley does not mean sending clean drinking water to residents—it means meeting corporate demands that waste water on fracking and unsustainable Big Ag industries,” she emphasized.
The Klamath and Trinity rivers witnessed the worst fall run Chinook salmon return in recorded history, leading to a disaster declaration in California and Oregon due to the loss of the commercial fisheries. The recreational fall Chinook salmon fishery in both the ocean and the Trinity and Klamath rivers was also closed in 2017.
The Yurok Tribe, California’s largest tribe, faced a subsistence allocation of just one fish per eight Tribal members, due to the Klamath River having the worst salmon run in history last year.
Hillman said the plan to increase water exports, in face of this disaster, is a “terrible, terrible idea.”
“We’re now to the breaking point,” Hillman said, “and we must reduce water use. If we keep allowing the corporate use of water for bad and unsustainable uses, the authorities are putting all lives and the environment in danger. People are starting to feel the effect over a long period of time...we can’t afford to live without water. The best thing is to take care of the river and restore it.”
On December 29, 2017, the Bureau of Reclamation announced it would conduct an environmental analysis of potential modifications to the operation of the Central Valley Project (CVP), in coordination with California’s State Water Project, to “maximize water deliveries” and “optimize marketable power generation.”
Although the plan is being currently promoted by the Donald Trump administration, it is based on legislation sponsored by Senator Dianne Feinstein and signed by President Barack Obama right before he left office in January 2017.
“We come here to speak a message of peace,” said Samuel Gensaw, Yurok Tribal Member and a traditional salmon fishermen from the Klamath River. “People have a right to protest. We will protest anything that poses a threat to our way of life.”
Dania Rose Colegrove, Hoopa Valley Tribe Member and organizer for the Klamath Justice Coalition, said 49 percent of the water from the Trinity, the largest tributary of the Klamath, is diverted to the Sacramento River through a tunnel that takes water from Trinity and Lewiston Dams through the Trinity Mountains into Whiskeytown Reservoir.
The water is then released from the Whiskeytown Dam into Clear Creek, a tributary to the Sacramento River, until it is diverted into the Delta Mendota Canal to be shipped to irrigators on the west side of the San Joaquin Valley.
“A couple of nuts are not worth destroying our rivers,” Colegrove emphasized, referring to the almonds, pistachios and other nuts grown by corporate agribusiness on the west side of the San Joaquin Valley with Trinity River water. “We oppose the taking of any more water from the Trinity. They can’t keep taking water from our river.”
Gary Mulcahy, governmental affairs representative for the Winnemem Wintu Tribe, said at the rally, “We are not here to speak a message of peace. We have been in a state of war with the Bureau of Reclamation. We were flooded out by Shasta Dam when it was built. We are fighting to bring back the original winter-run Chinook salmon to the McCloud River above the dam.”
He recalled that in the 1960s. “We could see so many salmon that we could nearly walk across them. Now you go to the salmon viewing area on the river and don’t see a single salmon. We plan to bring the salmon back by developing a volitional passageway to get the fish to the McCloud River above the lake.”
He wore a red hat with “Make America Sacred Again,” a play on the Trump campaign’s hat, “Make America Great Again,” and discussed the Tribe’s current efforts to return the fish, now thriving in New Zealand on the Rakaira River, to the fishery to the river above the dam.
The Tribe has been forced by NOAA Fisheries to pay for DNA testing to prove that the New Zealand fish are the original strain of the winter run, even though it is clear from planting records that the fish is indeed the original strain.
Morning Star Gali, Pit River Tribal Member, spoke on the devastating impact of the building of Shasta Dam and other dams on her tribe, which subsisted on salmon for many thousands of years before colonization. “We need our salmon returned,” she said.
Noah Oppenheim, Executive Director of the Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s Associations (PCFFA), discussed how California’s commercial salmon fishery was “mortally wounded” by a combination of the drought, catastrophic water mismanagement, and excessive south-of-Delta exports.
“Now the Bureau of Reclamation is here to twist the knife,” he explained. “What began last year as a non-jeopardy reinitiation of consultation has become a water grab fueled by greed and opportunism. If the Bureau gets its way, commercial and recreational salmon fishing will be lost forever in the Central Valley. Fishermen and anglers from the Golden Gate to Redding and all the way to Seattle need healthy salmon runs to survive.”
Regina Chichizola, a representative of Save California Salmon, said, “We are facing the worst salmon runs we have ever had on the Sacramento and Klamath Rivers due to bad water management during the drought, and the only thing that saved us from losing our drinking water supply last year was a rainy winter. California needs to start managing our water responsibly. The Trump plan is the opposite of responsible, and is especially troubling when the impacts of the Twin Tunnels and new dam proposals are factored in.”
Only 1,123 adult winter Chinook salmon returned to the Sacramento Valley in 2017, according to a report sent to the Pacific Fishery Management Council (PFMC) by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW). This is the second lowest number of returning adult winter run salmon since modern counting techniques were implemented in 2003. By comparison, over 117,000 winter Chinooks returned to spawn in 1969.
The decline of the winter run Chinook parallels the dramatic decline of spring run and fall run Chinook salmon, Central Valley steelhead, delta and long fin smelt, green sturgeon and a host of other species. In spite of a record water year in Northern California in 2017, the abundance of Delta smelt recorded in the CDFW’s annual fall midwater survey (FMWT) is the lowest in the survey’s 50-year history. Only two Delta smelt were collected at Delta index stations in October
The Delta smelt could be the first fish to to become extinct in the wild in the U.S. since President Nixon signed the landmark Endangered Species Act (ESA) in 1973. Maligned by the water contractors as a “little minnow,” the smelt is in fact an indicator species that demonstrates the health of the San Francisco Bay-Delta Estuary.
“With only two delta smelt identified in the last fish survey, state and federal agencies need to focus time, money, and energy on restoring smelt populations instead of turning up the pumps,” said Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla, Executive Director of Restore the Delta. “If California loses Delta smelt, the salmon will follow, then larger aquatic species that rely on salmon runs like Puget Sound Orcas will die off as well. We are looking at the potential collapse of an entire food chain.”
Other speakers at the rally included John McManus, the Executive Director of the Golden Gate Salmon Association; Thomas Joseph, a member of the Hoopa Valley Tribe; and Roger Mammon, President of the California Striped Bass Association, West Delta Chapter, and Secretary of the Board of Directors of Restore the Delta.
In addition to the Sacramento meeting, a meeting on the plan was also held in Los Banos on January 16 and in Chico on January 25. The overwhelming majority of people who spoke in the two meetings, including many farmers, spoke in opposition to it.
If you want to comment on the water export plan, you don’t have much time left. Written comments are due by close of business, Feb. 1, 2018, by U.S. mail or hand-delivery to Katrina Harrison, project manager, Bureau of Reclamation, Bay-Delta Office, 801 I Street, Suite 140, Sacramento, CA 95814-2536; fax 916-414-2439; or email firstname.lastname@example.org. For additional information, please contact Harrison at 916-414-2425 (TTY 800-877-8339).
A Notice of Intent to prepare an environmental impact statement in accordance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), “Revisions to the Coordinated Long-term Operation of the Central Valley Project and State Water Project, and Related Facilities” was published in the Federal Register, Friday, Dec. 29, 2017 and can be accessed at